What do we do? The struggle…
Colin is 19 months old. Actually, he’s 19 1/2 months old. He doesn’t sleep through the night. He’s never slept through the night. He doesn’t even sleep the 2 month old version of “through the night” - 5 hours. He sleeps like 2 hours, then wakes up screaming. Sometimes he sleeps 1 hour, sometimes 1/2 hour, sometimes 5 minutes. Sometimes he does sleep 4 hours, but most often thats from bedtime until 12 p.m. - 1 a.m. Sometimes I nurse him. Sometimes he just gets water.
Sometimes we get angry. Sometimes we are mean to each other. Sometimes we yell. Sometimes we say the “F” word. Sometimes we sleep-walk. Sometimes we can’t fall back to sleep. Sometimes Chris gets up. Sometimes I get up. Always we get up with him. Always we are moody and short tempered. Always we are tired. Sometimes we can’t function correctly. Always we are forgetful.
So what do we do? What is the solution? How can we get more sleep? What will it take? Is it possible? Why are both of our children like this? How did we fuck them up?
You might need a back-story before I continue. (By the way, this is shaping up to be a long post, so get comfortable).
We have always practiced attachment parenting. We have read and relied heavily on the writings of the great Drs. Sears. This has always felt right to us and this is how I would categorize “intuitive parenting” for our family. We didn’t set out to follow some parenting schema; this is just how we ended up parenting when we listened to our instinct. I don’t know why it has a name; I don’t know why it isn’t just regular old “Parenting,” but alas, we are attachment parents.
We don’t like to hear our children cry. We minimize their crying as much as possible. We don’t like to foster negativity. I know, I know…you are saying right now - WHO DOES? Well, I think we’ve always gone to great lengths to be even more understanding and more compassionate to/with our children. We have never intentionally put them in situations that we knew would be uncomfortable. We have tried to follow their lead as much as possible. We have tried to meet their needs and help them develop into independent little beings by offering them a strong, safe and secure foundation.
Fast forward…back to the topic at hand…
So we are obviously at our wit’s end. We aren’t nice parents. I don’t like the mommy I am becoming; I don’t like the mommy I have been. I certainly don’t like the wife I’ve been. I don’t like to be irritable. I don’t like to use TV as a babysitter because I just can’t do it (whatever it is at the moment). I don’t like to be mean to my husband. I don’t like that I’ve gained weight. I don’t like not having any energy. I don’t like feeling stressed out. I don’t like feeling unmotivated.
Solution? We don’t have one…yet. But I just received Dr. Ferber’s book Solve your Child’s Sleep Problems from PaperbackSwap. I’ve been reading the first few chapters looking for a compassionate solution. Most if it is the “DUH” info - of course he can’t fall asleep on his own because I’ve nursed him and/or Chris has rocked him to sleep every night of his life. When he wakes in the middle of the night, we pat his back, give him water or I nurse him again. He has sleep crutches. I know that. But an I break these sleep crutches without crying? No.
So we’re thinking of Ferberizing (or Ferberizing) Colin. There have been many critiques and stories on Ferberizing. Is it good? Is it not good? Does it cause damage to the nervous system? Is it worth it? Has Dr. Ferber changed his tune? Will it damage my baby forever? The answers: No, Yes, Yes, No, Maybe, Yes - or at least, this is what I have always believed. This is what my gut tells me.
But something has to happen. Somehow I need more sleep. Somewhere along the line this all got fucked up. It wasn’t supposed to be like this this time. I wasn’t going to make the same “mistakes” I made with Delaney. It was supposed to be easier. What happened?
So the question still looms…WHAT DO WE DO? Yes, I have “No Cry Sleep Solution.” I even have “No Cry Sleep Solution for Toddlers and Preschoolers,” both by Elizabeth Pantley. We did night wean Colin for the most part - from bedtime until 4 a.m. This doesn’t prevent him from waking up at 3 a.m., 3:15 a.m., 3:30 a.m., 3:45 a.m., 3:50 a.m., 3:55 a.m. and then 4 a.m. asking to nurse.
And if we do Ferberize him, how long will it take? Will I be able to handle it? Is he going to cry every night for the rest of his life? Am I setting up a bad precident? Am I damaging him forever? Part of me says “He is 19 months old…he has a level of understanding that a younger baby doesn’t have.” But then the other part says “He’s just a baby! And he will cry and cry and cry. Why do I want to to this to him?”
So the struggle continues. I keep waiting for him to grow out of this and start sleeping better. But I don’t know if I can wait that long.
January 26th, 2008 at 6:56 pm
Well, your problem, there is no “answer” Now having said this….lol…I am reading a book called “And Then I Had Kids” It is religous based, but that is not why I am reading it. I am reading it or should I say I started reading it to find a solution to our problem…terrible 3’s-hitting, lies, reversing back to occasional wetting, tantrums etc. What I have discovered, reassurances of the good things in our life. Example: Chip and I have similiar parenting styles and usually agree on things when it comes to her, finally waking up happy again as she used to when she was younger. So is it helping me solve the issues I was searching for…NO..it is helping me solve the other things so that I have the strength to deal with the moments of trouble.
Good luck and as everyone said-what 20 year old wears diapers? what 20 year old doesn’t sleep?
January 26th, 2008 at 9:38 pm
Oh how I know how you are feeling! It is, in fact, EXACTLY what we have been going through. Every day when I wake up without enough sleep AGAIN, I think to myself that I just CAN’T DO IT ANYMORE but then I remember that I don’t have a choice, I can’t just STOP being a mommy.
You didn’t mention the bitterness felt towards people whose children are easy sleepers who act like you’re an idiot because your child isn’t exactly like theirs. Or was that just me?
…Maybe we should just babysit for each other and take turns napping. =) Either way, I feel your pain. You’re not alone. And we WILL find a solution that gets us SOME sleep, somewhere, without breaking our children. I just don’t know when…
January 26th, 2008 at 9:55 pm
I’m not sure if you read it, but at the beginning of the month I stopped breastfeeding Amy to sleep and overnight. It was hard, it was FREAKING hard, but I did it.
I have a similar parenting philosphy to you with the attachment parenting. We shared a bed until it wasn’t working for us anymore.
The first day I stopped feeding her for her nap. She cried and I cried, but for the full 3 hrs it took her to go to sleep there was probably only an hour of crying, and most of that was while she was being held. In the end, it took her 10 seconds of crying alone to fall asleep.
That night it only took an hour of trying with 15 mins of crying. And she slept through the night.
What helped was - Not offering boob in her bed at ALL. Never. She knows now that if she gets into my bed of a morning she gets boob and I am fair game when we are anywhere else, but as soon as we get into her room, she doesn’t even ask for it.
- I give her a bottle of water to take to bed, because she gets thirsty. I am so anti bottle, so as soon as I find a good sippy cup that works, we will be swapping to that.
Good luck and it is hard. Admittedly Amy still doesn’t sleep through the night, although it has happened 3-4 times now. She generally wakes at about 1am needing a quick kiss and cuddle and her drink given back to her.